Image via Blackfly the Restaurant Blackfly the RestaurantĪ local favorite for unique fresh fish preparations (with selections like Wahoo, Mahi, and Hog Snapper), Blackfly the Restaurant will charm you with its bright artwork and murals and Bahamian ambiance even before the plate hits your table. Whatever you choose on the menu, you’ll be treated to a great value. If you want to add to the nautical charm, you can even travel there by boat and tie up at their dock before you dig into Shrimp and Grits, a Low Country Boil, and the Award-Winning Fish Soft Tacos.Īt Schooner’s Seafood House, you’ll find all your classic favorites – like Fried Clam Strips, crabcakes, oysters, and fish, boiled shrimp cocktail and conch fritters – but you’ll also get to try some dishes from the creek – like Frog Legs, Gator Tail, and a Swamp Platter (Frog Legs, Gator Tail, and lightly-fried Catfish). Situated in a grove of live oaks on the bank of the Tolomoto River, Aunt Kate’s is perfect for a laid-back waterfront experience. The menu is seasonal and local whenever possible, but on it you’ll find dishes like a Smoked Salmon Spread, Florida Shrimp Roll, Salmon BLT, Crab Cake Sandwich, and Rustic Fish – not to mention delicious craft cocktails. Not far from the main downtown drag, you’ll find this intimate little restaurant on Charlotte Street with a small menu that serves up big flavor. You can start with a half pound of Snow Crab Legs, then dine on a lobster tail or jumbo scallops, Seafood Pasta or Shrimp & Lobster Risotto.
Sitting just above the sand and so close to the ocean that you can taste the salt in the air, the atmosphere at The Reef practically requires that you sample their seafood. While you take in the breeze and sunshine on the Old Florida style deck, try out dishes like Southern Gumbo, She Crab Soup, and Gator Tail or Honey Rosemary Salmon, Sesame Seared Tuna, and oysters from the raw bar. This waterfront seafood restaurant sits on the shores of the Tolomato River, so you’ll get to experience a gorgeous view in addition to incredible food. Along the way, you’ll dine on Chowder Fries and Conch Fritters, Minorcan Conch and New England Clam Chowders, and Shrimp, Catch, and Oyster Baskets. Their laid-back restaurant is perfect for a fast casual bite or you can drop by their lounge for something a little more stylish. Augustine Seafood CompanyĪs their name implies, this is your St.